‘Can I Refinance While Buying a Second Home?’ Here Are the Mortgage Rule
Mar 12, 2022
As a buyer and a seller, you may be asking, “Can I refinance while buying a second home?” Maybe you’ve found a property that will be a killer investment at a bargain price. Or perhaps the beach cottage you’ve had your eye on for years just came on the market.
Whatever the reason, if you’re considering applying for another mortgage while refinancing your current home, the process can be a bit complicated. To give you the full picture, we consulted mortgage experts and broke down the rules.
‘Can I refinance an existing mortgage while buying a second home?’
There’s nothing wrong with refinancing one mortgage at the same time that you are buying an investment property or second home with a mortgage, according to Andrew Weinberg, principal and licensed mortgage broker at Silver Fin Capital Group, in Great Neck, NY.
The key factor to making both the refinance and new purchase work is to ensure you will qualify for the new home loan.
“This means taking into account your current home payment,” says Ralph DiBugnara, president of New York’s Home Qualified and vice president at Cardinal Financial. A mortgage bank can very easily tell you the total payments and loan amounts you’ll be able to carry based on your current income.
In some cases, you may even have to refinance to reduce your current mortgage payment to qualify for the new loan. Or you may need to cash out funds from the refinance to come up with the down payment on the new property.
The only ironclad rule is that you can’t refinance a primary residence while applying for a mortgage on a new primary residence.
Consider working with one lender for both mortgages
The benefit of doing both loans—refinancing and obtaining a new mortgage—is that you can deal with a single loan officer and provide most of your documents (e.g., tax returns, W-2s, pay stubs, bank statements, etc.) only once.
You can also optimize your loan balances and your monthly payment to a degree by doing both loans with the same lender, says DiBugnara.
If you need to work with two different lenders, both need to be aware of the other loan.
When refinancing and buying at the same time isn’t a good idea
You shouldn’t refinance a home you intend to sell in the next six months or so because it’s not cost-efficient.
“The closing costs don’t vary because you intend to pay off your loan in a short period of time,” says Weinberg.
Additionally, most refinances have a clause stating the borrower must stay in the home for at least one year. This means you cannot refinance a primary residence, close on a second home, and then immediately move into it permanently.
The differences between an investment and second home
When applying for your second mortgage, your lender will take into account how you plan on using the property. So it makes a difference if the second home is for investment purposes or is a vacation home for personal use.
“If the home is an investment, you can use proposed rental income as an add-on to your second income when qualifying for the second mortgage,” says DiBugnara.
But if you’re purchasing a vacation home, the new debt will count 100% against your current income and could prevent you from qualifying for a refinance and a second mortgage.
The good news for those looking to buy a beach cottage or winter retreat? Vacation home mortgage rates are typically lower than investment home rates.
“You can also typically put less money down—sometimes just 10%,” says Kylie Pak, owner of RedBrick Properties, in Richmond, VA, who specializes in property investing.